Non-partisan ministers and the risk of favouritism – political scientist assesses Latvia’s new government

Non-partisan ministers in Latvia’s new government could be more willing to make bold and unpopular decisions, political scientist Lelde Metla-Rozentāle, a lecturer at the Faculty of Social Sciences at Riga Stradiņš University, told LETA news agency.

She noted that a non-partisan minister may have no political ties or ambitions to pursue a long-term political career. In her view, under such circumstances, an industry professional could assess situations impartially and make decisions more boldly.

However, Metla-Rozentāle stressed that political decisions cannot always be based solely on calculations of profitability, financial benefits or losses. She cited healthcare, education and culture as examples of sectors where the state provides funding for activities that may not be financially profitable.

According to the political scientist, one of the main challenges for an industry professional serving as a minister is the ability to understand not only their own sector but also the needs of other sectors, listen to different perspectives and reach agreements. She believes that someone coming from a particular industry and seeking to defend its interests may struggle to recognise that the government must represent the interests of many different sectors.

Assessing the selection of ministerial candidates, Metla-Rozentāle identified three groups. Some candidates are people close to Prime Minister-designate Andris Kulbergs (United List), whom he knows from his previous professional activities and trusts. Others have demonstrated their professional expertise, while a separate group consists of representatives of the National Alliance (NA).

In her view, Kulbergs’ desire to involve familiar and loyal people in his team is understandable, provided they are professionally qualified and suitable for their positions. The political scientist acknowledged that such appointments could raise concerns about favouritism, but these could be addressed through communication demonstrating the candidates’ qualifications and suitability.

Discussing the government formation process, Metla-Rozentāle described its final stage as unexpectedly rushed. In her assessment, arguments about the lack of time have taken precedence over Kulbergs’ earlier emphasis on the quality of the process.

The political scientist referred to Kulbergs’ explanation that the parliamentary vote on the government could take place either on Tuesday or only in early December. Metla-Rozentāle argued that there had previously been sufficient time to avoid lengthy pauses and introduce ministerial candidates to the public earlier.

According to her, this would have allowed representatives of the relevant sectors to comment on the candidates and establish contact with them, although such feedback would not necessarily have had to influence ministerial appointments. She also believes that the government’s policy declaration could have been presented earlier in the formation process to demonstrate what agreements had been reached.

In her view, the quality of communication, the public’s opportunity to familiarise themselves with ministerial candidates and the government’s policy declaration have now taken a back seat, with speed dominating the process.

The political scientist emphasised that the National Alliance would wield considerable influence in the new coalition because the government would depend on its support. If Kulbergs does not want to rely on the backing of Ainārs Šlesers’ Latvia First party, he will have to take the National Alliance’s interests into account, she noted.

Commenting on relations between the United List (AS) and New Unity (JV), Metla-Rozentāle said that public statements had done little to improve understanding between the two political forces. She suggested that advice offered to Kulbergs by New Unity after the elections may have contributed to his sceptical attitude towards potential cooperation.

The political scientist also noted Šlesers’ repeated condition that he would support Kulbergs only if New Unity was excluded from the government. According to Metla-Rozentāle, part of society had demanded change, while New Unity was associated with the previous political period. She added, however, that neither the National Alliance nor the United List were newcomers to politics.

As previously reported, Kulbergs presented the composition and objectives of Latvia’s new government on Tuesday, appointing several non-partisan ministers to lead key sectors.

For example, Citadele Bank’s Chief Economist Kārlis Purgailis has been nominated for Minister of Finance, Amber Beverage Group board member Normunds Staņēvičs for Minister of Health, and Latvia’s Ambassador to Uzbekistan Ģirts Jaunzems for Minister of Foreign Affairs.

Kulbergs’ government will be formed by the United List and the National Alliance, which together hold a narrow majority of 51 seats in the Saeima. Šlesers has also pledged support for the government, although not all 17 MPs from his Latvia First party are expected to vote in its favour.